Post Overview: Gluten-free pizza in NYC
It’s estimated that 3.1 million Americans are gluten free, a figure that has been increasing over the years. Therefore there is a growing demand for gluten free pizza in NYC, the one meal that brings the city together.
Some folks have gluten allergies or celiac disease, and others merely avoid gluten for health reasons. At the end of the day your dietary restrictions are your own, but the demand for gluten free pizza in NYC is on the rise.
But where to do you go? Which restaurants have a health-conscious approach you can trust? This article is here to help you fill in those blanks and find the best gluten free pizza in NYC.
Some restaurants are entirely gluten free, others can make gluten free versions of popular pies. Regardless of what you’re searching for you’ll walk away from this article hungry and with a destination in mind.
So without further ado, what do you say we dive right in?
Visiting New York City? If you haven’t decided where to stay (yet) check out our helpful guide on Where to Stay in New York City (The best neighborhoods for first timers +2 to avoid). Don’t have time? Here’s our favorite hotel in NYC, hands down.
Gluten-Free Pizza in NYC
Bringing the authentic taste of Naples to Greenwich Village, Ribalta is a treasured New York City pizzeria. It’s not uncommon to hear Italian chatter among the guests and if Italians love it, you know its good.
Pasquale Cozzolino is founder of Ribalta, responsible for some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC. He’s mentioned that in Naples you have to apprentice for two years before they even let you touch the dough.
Crafting pie is an art, and Ribalta has gotten it down to a science. They make some of the best gluten-free pizza in New York City, every one of their pies can be made GF for an extra $6.
But there is one major caveat to this gluten free NYC pizza – I wouldn’t recommend for folks with celiac disease. All the pies are made in a common kitchen and cross contamination is possible.
For fans of soccer (especially Italian Serie A) Ribalta is a hotspot. They play games on a projector and the tables are full of food and drink with clamoring fans bickering, cheering, and celebrating.
And when the Italian national team plays? Welcome to Stadium Ribalta.
Address: 48 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003
#14. Double Zero
Matthew Kenney is a pioneer in the plant-based culinary world, having an arsenal of restaurants under his belt all across the country. One of them is Double Zero, a joint that provides some of the best gluten-free pizza in NYC.
The East Village pizzeria proves that a healthy diet and good food are not mutually exclusive. Their pies are incredible and can be made gluten free, vegan, or both.
And it isn’t a joint that only those with dietary restrictions will enjoy. Thanks to some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC even friends who have a liberal diet will leave with a full belly.
My only complaint is the seating arrangement.
I don’t mind that it’s full of people, I think it adds to the ambience. What I don’t like are the uncomfortable stools. I’d love to linger, enjoying a few rounds of beer and some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC but after a while my back gets tired.
Address:65 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003
#13. Don Antonio NYC
The culinary world of pizza is one that has been historically predominantly run by men, but at Don Antonio in Midtown, Giorgia Caporuscio is changing the stereotype.
She’s been dubbed the Queen of Neapolitan Pizza and it’s not hard to
see taste why. The menu at Don Antonio’s is made up of 45 different pies as well as seven different fried-pizzas, a dish popularized in Naples.
Each one of the pies can be made GF, so you have a wide array of the best gluten free pizza in NYC to choose from. You can view the full menu online, which also offers more gluten free options like salads and calzones.
But a word to the wise, Giorgia Caporuscio’s pies are a hot commodity. Folks visit from all five boroughs in search of the best gluten free pizza in NYC and unfortunately Don Antonio’s doesn’t take reservations, so be prepared for a short wait.
Address: 309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019
#12. Bleecker St. Pizza
Since opening shop in 2004 Bleecker St. Pizza has been a pizza enthusiasts dream come true. Serving delectable thin crust pies that let out an audible crunch with every bite you’ll be hard pressed not to order a slice for the road.
And lucky for us, they also make some of the best gluten-free pizza in NYC, tasty and available by the slice. Like an old school pizza joint there aren’t any fancy bells and whistles, just damn good pie.
Unlike other pizzerias that can make any one of their pies gluten free, Bleecker St. is mostly a slice shop so they can only have a few ready-made gluten free pies available. You’ll usually find a nona pie (their signature pie made with marinara, parmesan, mozzarella and basil) and a cheese pie that are gluten-free.
Expect lines but they move quickly, and if you want a whole pie order online or give them a call ahead of time. Otherwise you might have to hang out and wait, but it’ll be worth it for some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC.
Address: 69 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014
#11. Saraghina Restaurant
Bed-Stuy Brooklyn is home to some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC thanks to Saraghina Restaurant. Opened in 2009 it’s quickly become a neighborhood hot-spot, famous for its cozy interior vibe and summery outdoor dining.
A great date night spot, Saraghina Restaurant is sure to impress even the staunchest critic. Celiac or not, the gluten-free crust is a recipe that should be kept in the national archives, it’s that good.
Any one of their ten pies can be made gluten-free for an additional $5.
Besides some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC Saraghina Restaurant makes phenomenal Italian fare. Do yourself a favor and order the brussels sprouts, you won’t regret it.
Address: 350 Lewis Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233
#10. Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza
A stone’s throw away from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building, Tappo Thin Crust Pizza is a worthy addition to any NYC itinerary.
They make some of the best gluten-free pizza in NYC in a casual setting, reminiscent of an old-school neighborhood restaurant. Service is friendly and snagging a table is usually painless.
My birthday wish this year is that Tappo begins offering more gluten pizza, they only have one option. It’s a cheese pie made with a cauliflower, milled chia seeds and brown rice crust.
And Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza can also not guarantee a cross-contamination free kitchen, so folks with gluten allergies and celiac disease would be better served elsehwhere.
If Tappo had more options in a guaranteed, gluten free pie they’d be ranked higher on this list of the best gluten free pizza in NYC.
Address: 49 W 24th St, New York, NY 10010
Chef and owner of Kesté, Roberto Caporuscio, learned the secrets of making pizza in Naples. He opened successful pizzerias in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, before trying his hand in New York City, opening Kesté in 2009.
It’s is the type of place you go to when you want a fancy dinner, but are too much of a New Yorker not have pizza. A fine dining experience complete with an array of exceptional Italian wines, it’s a great spot for a relaxed date.
And dietary restrictions aren’t an issue at Kesté, they have some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC. In fact most every item on their menu can be made gluten free.
Kesté is also popular thanks to their fried pizza, and before you run off thinking it’s a greasy disaster you oughta give it a try. They use regular dough and fry it for 30 to 45 seconds, top it with the ingredients and throw it in the oven. When it comes out the oil has evaporated, the cheese has melted and presto, fried pizza.
Interesting tid-bit: Remember the pizzaiola at Don Antonio’s pizzeria, Giorgia Caporuscio? Well she’s the daughter of Roberto Caporuscio, pizzaiolo of Kesté. Making the best gluten free pizza in NYC is a family affair!
Address: 66 Gold St, New York, NY 10038
#8. Emmy Squared
Emmy Squared looks like a modern, trendy restaurant rather than a hole in the wall NYC pizza joint. They specialize in Detroit style pizza that’s square and boasts a thick crust, which is extremely satisfying if I do say so myself.
But this isn’t the place to come if you’re after a quick slice. Emmy Squared is a sit-down restaurant that provides the full dining experience, including drinks and desserts.
Any of their two-dozen pies can be made with gluten-free flower so you don’t have to choose between your health and your taste buds. It’s some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC, and there are vegan options too.
Getting a table at Emmy usually isn’t an impossible task, but if you’re planning to visit on the weekend I’d still encourage reservations. The last thing you want is to miss out on some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC.
Emmy Squared has five locations in Manhattan and two in Brooklyn, so make sure you reserve the right shop.
Address: Multiple locations in NYC
By blending Italian and Southern cuisines, Sauce has created the closest thing to heaven on earth. Food is hearty and filling, and the small-town vibe can make you forget you’re in the biggest city in America.
Folks in search of the best gluten free pizza in NYC will rejoice in learning that Sauce can make any of their pies on 10-inch cauliflower crust. Friends have told me they wish the pies were bigger, but I just see it as a way to try more variety.
The white-pie is a must order as far as I’m concerned. Made with fresh mozzarella, ricotta, red onion, sausage and hot honey you’ll be running back for more before the week’s over.
The biggest turn-off at Sauce is that although they make some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC, the $30+ price tag is rich for a 10 inch pie.
Address: Multiple locations in NYC
Wild has two locations, one in Park Slope, Brooklyn and one in the West Village. Both are entirely gluten free (can you hear the angels singing?).
Women owned and making mouthwatering Italian fare, Wild’s success shouldn’t come as a surprise.
Needless to say they make some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC, which is their specialty. The crust is extra thin and crispy, the sauce made from fresh tomatos and toppings that range from vegan cheese to lamb sausage.
And since the entire facility is gluten free folks with strict diets need not fret about cross contamination! You can enjoy your meal, assured that you’re eating 100% gluten free NYC pizza.
Address: 535 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014 & 148 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
If you’re looking for gluten free, NYC pizza Two Boots is here to satisfy.
But first you might be wondering what the pizzeria’s name even means! Two Boots was named after Italy and Louisiana, two places that (when looked at on a map) look like boots. The founders of Two Boots were inspired by Cajun cuisine and New-Haven (Connecticut) style pizza.
Founded in 1987 and now boasting five (soon to be six) colorful and quirky locations in NYC, Two Boots will make any one of their pizza pies gluten free for you.
You should also note that every Two Boots location has a signature “home” pie that’s unique to the neighborhood. You can check them out online and make a bee line to the one that sounds most appetizing or try them all!
Address: Multiple locations in NYC
#4. Williamsburg Pizza
Don’t let the name throw you off — Williamsburg Pizza isn’t exclusive to Williamsburg Brooklyn (they even have a location in Nebraska). They have three locations in Brooklyn and two in Manhattan.
The friendly and extremely efficient staff do a great job at creating a welcoming environment for folks to enjoy a classic slice of gluten free NYC pizza.
Those who are partial to a bit of a crispy, crunchy crust are sure to be satisfied. Nice and toasty, the crust’s flavor isn’t overwhelming which really helps the quality ingredients really shine.
A bit of fair warning though, most of the slices available at Williamsburg Pizza aren’t gluten free. You’ll have to order your pie ahead of time and put in the request to have it made gluten free.
Address: 1617 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
Emily is a small business founded by husband and wife duo Matt and Emily Hyland. Since opening in 2014 their food has spoken for itself. It’s organically become a NYC favorite, attracting tourists, locals and even celebrities.
And although I return time and time again for their mouthwatering burger (which unfortunately isn’t gluten free) I can’t forget to mention that Emily also makes some of the best gluten-free pizza in NYC!
For an extra $4 you can make any one of Emily’s pizzas a gluten-free indulgence. The pizzas are Detroit style, so expect filling square pies that are thick and generously garnished with toppings.
I’m partial to the Good Paulie, which is a white pie that comes with caramelized onions, sausage and smoked gouda but whichever pie you choose, Emily makes some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC.
Address: 35 Downing St, New York, NY 10014 & 919 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Rubirosa is a classic New York pizza joint beloved by locals and tourists alike, for good reason. They have perfected the art of marinara sauce, so much so, that I’d eat it by the spoonful if it were on the menu.
Where to start with the pizza? It’s perfect by all standards. The crust is perfectly charred and thin, the sauce is on the light side and the generous globs of cheese are as chewy as they should be.
Lucky for you they also make some of the best gluten free pizza in NYC. Quality is uncompromised, regardless of dietary conditions.
The reason I think Rubirosa is the BEST pizza in New York City is simple — I am
satisfied excited by the simplest pizza known to man.
How can a combination of crust, marinara sauce and cheese be so memorable? I’m guessing the secret is in the quality ingredients and a delicious gluten free NYC pizza crust. I would eat here every day if I could.
Address: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012
Quick Recap of the best gluten-free pizza in New York City
- Williamsburg Pizza
- Emmy Squared
- Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza
- Bleecker St. Pizza
- Don Antonio NYC
- Double Zero
Best Gluten-Free Pizza NYC (Helpful Map)
And there you have it, our list of the best places to grab gluten free pizza in NYC. As always, don’t hesitate to let us know if we missed anything.