Skip to Content

8 Cheerful Chelsea Bakeries (You Won’t Soon Forget!)

Starbucks Roastery in NYC, best bakeries Chelsea

Looking for the best bakeries in Chelsea? Well, you’re in luck! As a local with a weakness for bakeries, I can attest that self-control goes out the window when you’re surrounded by tempting treats in New York City. I might have to distribute flyers warning Chelsea bakeries to resist my impulse to buy everything, as credit card explanations to my husband are becoming a challenge.

Chelsea bakeries have a way of luring you in with their overflowing pastry cases. But hey, enough of the small talk. What do you say we get to the good stuff?

Visiting New York City? If you haven’t decided where to stay (yet) check out our helpful guide on Where to Stay in New York City (10 Best Neighborhoods +3 to Avoid). Don’t have time? Here’s our favorite hotel in NYC, hands down.

Best Chelsea Bakeries

Table of Contents: Bakeries in Chelsea

Fabrique Bakery

Website: Fabrique Bakery
Address: 348 W 14th St, New York, NY 10014

Fabrique Bakery, considered one of the best bakeries in Chelsea, offers heavenly baked goods that you can smell from a block away. Everything is made in-house for a consistently fresh experience. Originally from Stockholm, this Swedish bakery now has locations in London and New York City.

Their cardamom buns are a must-try, known for their perfect density and rich flavor. Picture a cross between a cinnamon roll and pull-apart bread—soft and flaky inside, crunchy outside, and filled with a sugary cardamom dusting. Head to Fabrique for a unique and delicious treat.

Amy’s Bread (Chelsea Market)

Website: Amy’s Bread
Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011

Walk into Amy’s Bread on any weekend morning and you’ll find yourself lost in a sea of locals eager to get their hands on a baked good from this beloved Chelsea bakery. The chocolate cake at Amy’s Bread is truly exceptional—rich, moist, and perfectly airy, crowned with a delectable “chocolate silk” topping. It’s a top pick for anyone planning an event and in need of a full-sized cake.

For those who don’t speak “sugar” like it’s their second language, no worries. Amy’s Bread bakes delicious loaves of bread (on site) that cannot be missed. This Chelsea bakery has been a staple in Chelsea Market since 1996 and does not plan on going anywhere, anytime soon.

Empire Cakes, Best Bakeries Chelsea

Empire Cakes

Website: Empire Cakes
Address: 112 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011

Empire Cake, a standout bakery in Chelsea, is conveniently located just two blocks from the High Line, one of NYC’s most unique parks. They specialize in daily-fresh pastries crafted from quality local ingredients. Their red velvet cupcakes are particularly mouthwatering, featuring real cream cheese frosting that perfectly complements the silky red velvet. Another crowd favorite is their gourmet “snack cakes,” a fresh take on Twinkies available in flavors like lemon and passionfruit. Plus, Empire Cake is one of the best bakeries in Chelsea for events, offering wedding cakes, custom cupcakes, and decorated cookies for any occasion.

Sullivan Street Bakery
Chelsea Bakeries
Image Courtesy Sullivan Street Bakery

Sullivan Street Bakery and Pizza

Website: Sullivan Street Bakery and Pizza
Address: 236 9th Ave, New York, NY 10001

Jim Lahey, the founder of Sullivan Street Bakery, brought a touch of European artistry to the heart of Chelsea. Having studied art in Europe, he returned to New York City only to find a lack of the enticing bread he had grown to love abroad. Determined to fill that gap, Lahey took matters into his own hands and founded Sullivan Street Bakery in 1994, now widely recognized as one of the best bakeries in Chelsea’s.

A true artist, Lahey meticulously sources the finest ingredients, adheres to tradition, and personally shapes every bread by hand. The bakery’s sweet treats, like the irresistible bombolini, a traditional Italian donut often filled with jelly or custard, are equally noteworthy and fulfill every dream.

However, Sullivan Street Bakery isn’t just about bread; they’ve also mastered the art of pizza-making at their Chelsea location, and I can personally attest to its deliciousness!

Bourke Street Bakery

Bourke Street Bakery

Website: Bourke Street Bakery
Address: 162 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011

Bourke Street Bakery is new to the scene, opening in 2021. This Chelsea bakery hails from Australia — originally opening in Sydney more than 15 years ago. Offering a plethora of delightful baked goods, the bakery is best known for their famous meat pies and sausage rolls. No seriously, the thing has won numerous awards! Give it a try for yourself and see what all the fuss is about.

I recommend ordering the shakshuka egg & feta Danish. The egg is perfectly runny and the texture of the danish is incredible. Oh! Don’t even think about leaving without ordering a loaf of the sourdough bread from one of the best bakeries in Chelsea.

Billy’s Bakery

Website: Billy’s Bakery
Address: 184 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011

Billy’s Bakery in Chelsea is my go-to spot for a reliably delicious sweet treat. With a range of tempting cake flavors like banana, lemon raspberry, and coconut, it’s tough to pick just one favorite. The standout, though, has to be their famous icebox cake – layers of fresh whipped cream between crispy chocolate wafers, available in chocolate, peppermint, or vanilla. It’s simply perfect. Whether I’m in the mood for a quick cake fix or a cup of coffee, Billy’s Bakery never disappoints.

Modern Bread and Bakery

Website: Modern Bread and Bakery
: 139 W 14th St, New York, NY 10011

Modern Bread and Bagel in Chelsea is undeniably one of the best bakeries in town, and what sets them apart is their dedication to being entirely gluten-free. They’ve mastered the art of crafting delicious treats and bagels without compromising on taste or texture. With a diverse menu of gluten-free delights and a commitment to quality ingredients, it’s no wonder they’re a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re gluten-sensitive or just love fantastic baked goods, this bakery is a must-visit in Chelsea.

Seven Grams Chocolate Chip Cookie, Best Cookies in New York City

Seven Grams Caffe

Website: Seven Grams Caffe
Address: 275 7th Ave, New York, NY 10001

Seven Grams Cafe is famous for its outstanding gooey chocolate chip cookies and excellent espresso. The cafe’s name comes from the belief that a perfect shot of espresso requires exactly 7 grams of premium coffee grounds. The coffee is simple but incredibly satisfying, emphasizing smoothness and bold flavor. While the Chelsea bakery is not exclusively gluten-free, Seven Grams stands out by offering options for dietary restrictions, including gluten-free/vegan cookies, scones, and granola bars.

Best Bakeries Chelsea (Post Summary)

In summary, these are the best bakeries in the Chelsea:

  • Billy’s Bakery
  • Bourke Street Bakery 
  • Sullivan Street Bakery and Pizza
  • Empire Cakes
  • Amy’s Bread
  • Fabrique Bakery 
  • Modern Bread and Bakery 
  • Seven Grams Caffe

Further Reading for Chelsea

Fun Things to Do in Chelsea: 15 Things to Do in Chelsea
Best Brunch in Chelsea: 15 Fantastic Spots for Brunch in Chelsea NYC
Best Coffee in Chelsea: 15 Charming Coffee Shops in Chelsea 
Happy Hour Spots in Chelsea: 18 Satisfying Happy Hours in Chelsea, New York City

Neighborhoods Near Chelsea Worth Checking Out

Restaurants in Greenwich Village: 12 Charming Restaurants in Greenwich Village
Happy Hour in the West Village: 10+ Wonderful West Village Happy Hour Spots
Coffee Shops in Greenwich Village: 12 Gorgeous Greenwich Village Coffee Shops
Best Bars in the Greenwich Village: 15 Boozy Bars in Greenwich Village

Bakeries in Chelsea NYC (Map)

I hope you enjoyed this list of the best bakeries in Chelsea. Don’t hesitate to let me know if you think I missed anything, I’ll happily check it out.